Skip to main content

Interview with Andy Biddle and Noah Harris, Directors of Stop Motion Short Film "Salvation"

Noah Harris and Andy Biddle take us on a breathtaking journey through time and space to explore the story of man and human nature, every facet of which they exemplify in collected detritus – knick-knacks and other odd artifacts – each item personifying a different aspect of humanity – from our most tragic flaws to our greatest achievements – in their new short film, Salvation.

The origin for Salvation – the compilation of a series of eight interconnected films, created by Andy and Noah – began with a collaboration between the animation production company Blinkink and the record label Village Green Recordings to create a series of films featuring various songs from Village Green’s 2017 roster – a project which was supported by and premiered on Random Acts. Each film is short, ranging from 22 to 33 seconds long, and explores a chapter in the overall narrative arc of a poignantly poetic summation of humanity’s most spectacular nadirs and highpoints. It begins in the first film, “Element,” with the origins of life and eventually follows humankind down into its twisty history. A path which leads to mankind’s religious devotion, human handiwork and industrialization, ultimate corruption and eventual downfall, finally ending with a film entitled “Lazarus,” exemplifying redemption, rebirth, and eternity.



Noah and Andy’s method for making these films was quite an organic process: Noah, co-director of the films, began the project with defining eight separate categories, each of which covered one chapter in the overall narrative, and for which the titles for the films illustrate: “Element,” “Life,” “Sentience,” “Devotion,” “Industry,” “Decadence,” “Oblivion,” and “Lazarus.” From there, Andy – co-director and lead animator on the films – and Noah made many visits to car boot sales and flea markets around London in search of odd objects that generally go unnoticed or are otherwise undervalued that they felt embodied a certain part of each theme. Each of these objects – some of which were painted gold or otherwise altered – were then selected to appear in the film with whose theme they most appropriately fit. Each object was then animated entirely in-camera – primarily by Andy, but there’s some additional animation that’s the work of animator Luke George.

The films are beautiful and sublime, highlighting objects and subject matter that are rarely implemented in stop motion films. You can go watch the full series here, the compilation film – Salvationhere, or you can go watch each of the films individually by clicking on the following links for the corresponding films: #1 Element, #2 Life, #3 Sentience, #4 Devotion, #5 Industry, #6 Decadence, #7 Oblivion, #8 Lazarus. You can also see the making-of video here.

Thanks to Noah and Andy, who I recently had the chance to interview about the creative process on Salvation, in which we went over challenges they met along the way, creative partnership versus a singular creative vision, advice to young creatives, as well as many many more topics. You can read our full interview below.

A.H. Uriah: Each of the eight films in the Salvation series explores one major concept in the story of man and the cycle of life, as are described by the titles of each film: “element,” “life,” “sentience,” “devotion,” “industry,” “decadence,” “oblivion,” and, lastly, “Lazarus.” From both an artistic and creative standpoint, what was the evolution of the film itself – from original conception to final product? What choices did you make along the way that shaped the final film, transforming it from the film you originally envisioned?

Noah Harris: The whole idea behind the project was that it would be an organic and evolutionary process. The narratives within each film were loosely planned, but were driven by the objects we found…

I work a lot in advertising, where everything is meticulously planned prior to shooting… and this was an opportunity to allow a project to evolve in a more explorative way. Andy and I would go to a car boot sale with some words and concepts – Sentience, Oblivion etc… and just try and find amazing objects that related to those words… From the outset the plan was that the car boot sales had to lead the narratives… We would work with what we found… Obviously as the project progressed we started to choose sets of objects and create narratives… We could start to see how certain objects would become other objects… what colours we would use, and how we could shoot them…

Overall, for me, film-making is a very collaborative process. As more people get involved, they bring their skills, knowledge and ideas and throw them in the melting pot. There is always a creative evolution underway.

Andy Biddle: These films were really born from a music video I worked on alongside Noah Harris (Peppermint by Julio Bashmore). In that film we used found objects to create metamorphism through animation. It turned out to be an extremely successful technique and it was a process that both Noah and I really enjoyed. Noah approached me last summer with the idea of co-directing a series of films for the music label Village Green. At this point he had already roughed out the themes for each of the eight states of evolution but we still needed to establish exactly what was going to happen in each film. Unlike Peppermint, these films were to be far more reliant on found objects and this meant that Noah and I spent many a weekend scouring car boot sales and charity shops looking for objects that might work for each film. On these outings we generally had a wish list for certain objects, however we weren’t always able to find what we wanted. We did however find many obscure objects that inspired very different compositions and actions which were far more interesting and exciting than some of our original ideas.

A.H.: Noah, Salvation isn’t the first project that you and Andy have worked on together, and I really hope that it won’t be the last. Your creative partnership interests me greatly as they rarely seem to work out. However, you and Andy have found a unique equilibrium in your creative partnership. How would you describe the creative dynamic between you and Andy, in what ways do your skill-sets complement each other, and, from your experience, how does the creative process differ in partnership versus being the sole creative mind on a project?

NH: We’ve worked together on projects for a long time yes, generally with me as director and Andy as lead animator. I guess we’ve developed a language between us over the years… Andy knows what I’m talking about when I start discussing some weird cryptic shit (or at least he pretends to) and I know his animation is going to take the shot to a whole new level.

I like to think I use stop frame in quite a nontraditional way. Really to me it’s just a way of making real objects move… I generally don’t set out to make a ‘stop frame’ film… I love it when people think we’ve done it in CG. Andy’s precision and skill mean we can really transcend the feel some stop frame has.

Some projects are suited to one over-riding creative mind, whereas others really benefit from creative collaboration. Salvation is the meeting point of art direction and animation. So for Andy and I to co-direct made perfect sense.

A.H.: From a technical and practical animation standpoint, what were the most challenging aspects of the production, how did you cope with them, and what, if anything, did you learn from these challenges?

AB: The production value of this project very much outweighed the budget we had. This was an especially challenging aspect of the whole project. We were very much up against it in terms of time and equipment and every favour we had in our back pocket was used. We shot all eight of these films in ten days which was extremely tight time-wise. As well as being a co director I was feverishly animating my socks off while a second unit was being prepared by our director of photography; Toby Howell. We had to have at least two units on this shoot so that both Toby and I could “leap frog” over each other everyday. On day one I would be animating in unit 1 while he prepared unit 2 and on the second day we would switch.

One film which proved to be extremely difficult technically and practically hard was “Element.” This is the very first film in the series and while it doesn’t contain the amount of objects some of the other films do, it was definitely the hardest to execute. For example, each frame required six different lighting states which all had to be reconfigured manually since we could not afford DMX (hardware that does this lighting change automatically). It was also very rig-heavy as everything was in the air and there wasn’t much room for a change in choreography, so trying to get this 15-second-film in one day with all these extra challenges was quite a task.



A.H.: At this point, you’ve worked in the creative filmmaking and animation industry for a significant amount of time. What advice would you give to young animators who are just starting out professionally in the industry, or who are considering starting a professional career? Are there any resources you would recommend to them?

NH: My career has been pretty organic really, from graphic design, through TV branding, and now directing. There aren’t any particular things I did that I could pick out as advice. I think the mix of passion and dedication are key. You need to work hard to stand out in creative industries. And the best way to work hard is to do what you love… or love what you do. I love it when I meet people who are not only talented but display an infectious enthusiasm for what they do. It means they dig a bit deeper, they’re not afraid to explore and try out new things…

AB: I graduated university in 2004 with my animation degree eager to get a job doing anything in the animation industry. However it proved to be hugely difficult to even get unpaid work experience with studios production companies but over time I managed to secure some work experience placements. One of these led to a position as a production runner at a company called Calon working on a kids tv show called Hana's Helpline and it was there I started to animate professionally. This job led to animating on Fantastic Mr. Fox and that job lead on to working at Laika. I consider myself to be pretty lucky that my career snowballed this quickly. It was a hard path though and there were a few times early on when I considered throwing in the towel. So to answer your question, my advice to any aspiring animators out there is to do as many internships as possible as the more experience you have the more likely you are to get to where you want to. To keep practicing animating. Always try to better the last piece of animation on your showreel and finally, don’t give up.



Andy and Noah both have extraordinarily prolific careers – Andy primarily in stop motion and Noah as a director and designer primarily in advertising.

Noah’s work in music videos and advertising has led to a delicious amount of stop motion projects (including several collaborations with Andy), ranging from his work for companies such as Google, Brother Printers and Kia, and for music artists such as Julio Bashmore. You can go see more of his work by visiting his Vimeo channel and website.

Andy’s career in stop motion has a very wide range, going from his work on feature-length films such as ParaNorman, My Life as a Zucchini, Fantastic Mr. Fox, The Grand Budapest Hotel, and Wes Anderson’s upcoming stop motion film, Isle of Dogs. He also has done some incredible work in short films, music videos, adverts, and television – all of which have led to him to becoming one of the most prolific and talented masters of the medium. You can go see more of his work on his Vimeo channel.

If you’re interested in reading another interview with Andy and Noah about Salvation, you can go here, which is with the excellent filmmaking blog “Director’s Notes.”


















Popular posts from this blog

Interview with Heather Colbert, Director and Animator of Ori Dagan's Jazzy Nat King Cole Homage "Bibimbap"

A stop motion iteration of Toronto-based jazz musician Ori Dagan straightens his glossy red bowtie and straightens his hat – the kind that jazz icon Nat King Cole often wore – as he taps his foot to the beat of a lively and blissful piano. Then, looking directly into the camera, he raises an eyebrow and begins to sing.

“He downed a sweet Bellini in the hometown of Fellini. He ordered fresh linguine with pancetta and rapini. But nothing could ever compare to Bib…im…bap,” Dagan reminisces happily in his rich baritone as the delicacies actualize out of midair, a glass of Bellini appearing in his hand and a pile of linguine raining down on him from above in Bristol-based stop motion animator Heather Colbert’s Bimimbap.


Bibimbap is Heather Colbert’s outstanding contribution to Toronto-based Ori Dagan’s “visual jazz album” for his album “Nathaniel: A Tribute to Nat King Cole,” for which Dagan collaborated with many filmmakers and animators to create music videos for each of the songs on the…

Interview with Mark Smith, Director and Writer of Stop Motion Short Film, "Two Balloons"

As I sit, listening to Peter Broderick’s moving composition for piano More Of A Composition, I close my eyes and envisage an enormous funnel cloud skimming across the crystalline face of an ocean – the skies are murky and unusually dark, lightning crackles, spider-webbing across the darkened skies before then vanishing, and still, after its gone, an electricity continues to hum in the air and I simply know that it’s going to soon strike again. And as the scene presents itself to me, I suddenly feel something similar to what director Mark C. Smith felt when he saw the same image as he sailed to a small island called Grenada along with his wife in a timeworn sailboat. For him, in that moment inspiration struck, and the idea suddenly came to him for his heartfelt stop motion film, Two Balloons. For me, I open my eyes and feel as I did the instant Two Balloons faded to black – as if I’ve just woken from a stunning and beautiful dream, one I immediately mourn not being able to see again f…

Aardman Senior Model-Maker Jay Smart Reveals Aardman's Puppet Materials and Plasticine Techniques for "Early Man" to Adam Savage of Tested

Along with the usual humdrum of press ranging from critic reviews and interviews with voice actors regarding British animation powerhouse Aardman Animation’s latest feature film – Early Man, a “prehistoric underdog sports story,” in the words of the film’s director Nick Park – has come by the way of the YouTube channel Tested something really exceptional and especially meant for stop motion enthusiasts – a deep-dive into the materials and plasticine techniques Aardman uses for their puppets presented by television personality and special effects aficionado Adam Savage and Jay Smart, a senior modeler at Aardman.

During Savage’s tour of the plasticine department, Smart gives Savage a demonstration of a system Aardman began developing for Chicken Run, their first plasticine-driven feature film, to methodize a system for mixing large batches of plasticine to produce a particular, standardized color of plasticine. The technique developed, it turns out, was to amalgamate several different …

"Early Man" Assistant Director Ben Barrowman Explains Incredibly Detailed Process of Scheduling an Aardman Production to Adam Savage of Tested

In Stop Motion Geek’s third week of featuring the YouTube channel Tested’s excellent behind-the-scenes look at Early Man – the most recent stop motion feature film from Aardman Animations – special effects devotee Adam Savage interviews Early Man first assistant director Ben Barrowman, the mastermind behind Aardman’s “schedule boards” and the coordinator of the entire production schedule for the film.

“Schedule boards” is the term that the folks at Aardman Animations use to refer to the rows upon rows of massive cork boards which are used to plot out the schedule across an entire feature-length production and that are positioned on mobile wall-mounts, one next to another, together spanning an entire wall of one of the studio’s buildings.


The boards are seemingly inauspicious – light gray in color and well-worn from the hundreds of thumb tacks by which they have been impaled since their introduction on Aardman’s second feature-length production, 2005’s Wallace & Gromit: Curse of …

Interview with Joseph Wallace, Director of Spark's "Edith Piaf (Said It Better Than Me)" Official Music Video

Neon feathers fly and a midnight chase ensues in a 1930s’ Paris imagined by BAFTA Cymru nominated director Joseph Wallace, traversing through streets, caf├ęs, and across rooftops sporting tilted chimneys and scaly shingles in the music video for legendary American pop-alternative band Sparks’ latest hit, “Edith Piaf (Said It Better Than Me),” praised by the band as, “Perhaps Sparks’ best video ever.”


The video is a gorgeous and somewhat psychedelic romp through the stylized 1930s’ Paris cityscape – “Piaf’s Paris,” as dubbed by Wallace – through which we follow stop motion versions of the Mael brothers, Ron and Russell, whom together comprise Sparks, as they follow a large, neon-colored bird – a sight that provides a stark contrast to the otherwise moody, muddy color palette of Wallace’s Paris, composing a beautiful and exciting ambiance of 3-and-a-half-plus minutes of pure cinematic bliss.

The world of the film was built primarily using cardboard, the backgrounds were painted panorama…

Aardman Model-Making Workshop Manager Jimmy Young Displays Aardman's Puppet-Making Techniques for "Early Man" to Adam Savage of Tested

Upon moving from Aardman’s plasticine workshop to the heart of their model-making department, all around special effects enthusiast Adam Savage – outfitted in his iconic, plain black t-shirt, beige fedora, and thick-rimmed glasses – is greeted by an in-depth display of half a dozen of the puppets designed, engineered, and built for Nick Park’s Early Man and by Aardman senior model maker and model making worship manager Jimmy Young – donning a plaid, blue-and-white button-up with the sleeves rolled up as well as glasses and a black “DC” baseball hat. Young proceeds to explain to Savage Aardman’s process of puppet building and model making in Tested’s most recent video documenting Savage’s in his tour of Aardman.


“Jimmy, when you came to my cave last year you brought some of your amazing handiwork and gave me a little taste of your guys’ wonderful engineering of these puppets,” begins Savage, referencing this video, in which Young and Aardman senior model maker Gary Roberts gave anothe…

Interview with Kangmin Kim, Director of Stop Motion Short Film, "Deer Flower"

The experience of childhood is something like existing within a waking dream. In childhood, as in particularly vibrant dreams, the distinct and unique experience presents itself to simply exist in each moment without explanation or reflection – to become fully and wholly enveloped in each and every moment, the option of operating outside of which is somehow nonexistent. In that special time in one’s life, moments simply are. And yet, childhood, like dreams, is a fragile and temporary reality. It’s not until one “wakes” from childhood, by entering adulthood, that one can reflect upon and appreciate the past and, in retrospect, realize just how odd and unusual certain experiences might have actually been. Korean filmmaker and animator Kangmin Kim captures this feeling beautifully in his outstanding short film Deer Flower.

Deer Flower tells the semi-autobiographical of auteur Kangmin Kim’s childhood experience of dealing with persistent illness and of taking one of the remedies his paren…

Interview with Niki Lindroth von Bahr, Director, Writer, and Animator of Stop Motion Short Film "Bath House"

In art as in life, when in the thick of something – a chain of, at times, loosely connected actions and consequences – it can be easy to miss “the point.” It’s often only in retrospect – the moment when one can contemplate, assessing and reassessing an event, whether mundane or abnormal – when one can discover meaning and a “point” to events in life as in art. When in the thick of something, things often feel commonplace, moments of actual weight sporadic, chaotic, and adrift, lost in the moment.

Niki Lindroth von Bahr’s Bath House – a 15-minutes-long short film – perfectly captures these feelings of disorder and inconsequential consequence in the midst of the mundane and seemingly aimless. This mood is further accentuated in the film by a disquieting lack of a soundtrack, using dialogue only sparingly which perfectly accompanies Bahr’s incredibly lifelike puppets and animation, together harmonizing and bringing to life moments and an atmosphere that are rarely (if ever) captured on …

"Welcome To My Daydream" Documentary About Stop Motion Filmmaker Will Vinton Now on Kickstarter

With four days left to go on Kickstarter, the documentary about the Oscar-winning filmmaker and Claymation filmmaker, Will Vinton, Welcome To My Daydream, climbs steadily towards its goal of $35,000 with 10k left to raise.

Will Vinton, one of the stop motion industry’s most undervalued pioneers – who, in 1978, coined and trademarked the term “Claymation” – was the founder of Will Vinton studios, under which he contributed to creating iconic Claymation characters such as the California Raisins, ‘80s Domino’s mascot Noid, the non-Claymation Red and Yellow M&M’s, as well as having spearheaded Claymation films such as The Adventures of Mark Twain and A Claymation Christmas Celebration, as well as dozens of other feature-length and short films.

Welcome To My Daydream tells the little-known saga of Will Vinton’s career and the and rise and fall of Will Vinton Studios, a stop motion production company founded with high hopes only to eventually fizzle out in the early 2000s, bereft of fund…

Interview with Bruno Caetano, Co-Director of Stop Motion Music Videos "Cinegirasol" and "Fundo da Garrafa" for Portuguese Band "Os Azeitonas"

There are few things that are quite like heartbreak – heartbreak of the soul-crushing kind: More than any commonly shared languages or cultural beliefs or social practices is something so universally shared and understood as the pain of heartbreak. However, what makes heartbreak so odd, so unique next to other kinds of pain, is its ability to confine its casualty in a feeling – a prison of a kind isolation that is amazingly personal, inexplicable, and easily crippling. There seems, of course, an easy fix – communication, sharing past pain, past heartbreaks. Words, however, so often fail us. And yet, there is a cure, albeit one that gets so often overlooked. It lingers, waiting to be discovered after the rest have failed. The cure is called art, and its remedy for heartbreak can lie in unexpected places – a cluttered attic, a dormant Netflix queue, a musical instrument that has long since been forgotten. Perhaps its healing power comes from its extraordinarily personal quality, which a…